If your company were buying another business, you wouldn’t start with the seller’s revenue projections. You’d start with the management team, the books and the deal terms. Then you’d look at the forecast, knowing it was written to win you over.
Private real estate deserves the same order of operations. Yet many executives evaluating a fund or syndication start with the projected return on page one of the pitch deck. That number is only as good as the team and the structure behind it.
Here’s a framework for evaluating private real estate the way you’d evaluate any other investment decision at work.
Why does the sponsor matter so much right now?
Because the market is sorting strong operators from weak ones. Commercial real estate is still working through the effects of higher borrowing costs. The Trepp CMBS delinquency rate stood at 7.87% in October 2026, with office loans at 12.33% and multifamily at 8.09%, according to CRE Daily’s report on Trepp data.
Those averages hide a wide spread. In the same market, some sponsors are refinancing on schedule and paying distributions while others are handing keys back to lenders. The difference usually comes down to how much debt they took on, when it matures and how well they run the property.
Returns across the broader market have been modest. The NFI-ODCE index of large core real estate funds returned 4.45% gross for the year ended June 30, 2026, according to NCREIF. In a market like that, a pitch projecting far higher returns deserves extra scrutiny of how the sponsor expects to get there.
What are the main ways to invest in private real estate?
Private real estate covers several structures, each with a different balance of control, diversification and liquidity:
| Option | What you own | Your control | Typical commitment |
| Direct ownership | The property itself | Full | Until you sell |
| Syndication | A share of one property | Low; sponsor decides | Often five to seven years or more |
| Private equity fund | A share of several properties | Low; manager picks deals | Often years, with limited exits |
| Private debt fund | Loans secured by real estate | Low; manager underwrites loans | Varies by fund terms |
For a closer comparison of these structures and a step-by-step evaluation order, this guide on evaluating private real estate options walks through each one from an investor’s point of view.
How should you evaluate the team?
Treat the sponsor like a management team you’re backing. Questions worth asking:
- What have they actually delivered? Ask for realized returns on deals they’ve exited, including any that lost money. Projections and “target IRRs” aren’t a track record.
- Did they operate through a downturn? A sponsor whose entire history sits inside a rising market hasn’t been tested.
- Do they own the operations? Sponsors who manage their own properties have more control over costs and tenant experience than those who outsource everything.
- How much of their own money is in? Meaningful co-investment aligns their outcome with yours.
- How do they communicate bad news? Ask for a past investor letter from a deal that struggled.
What should you look for in the deal structure?
Once the team checks out, read the structure as closely as you’d read a term sheet:
- Debt: loan-to-value, fixed or floating rate, and the maturity date. A loan maturing into a tough refinancing market can wipe out equity.
- Fees: acquisition, asset management, financing, disposition and the sponsor’s share of profits. Model them in dollars on a sample commitment.
- Distribution waterfall: who gets paid first, any preferred return, and how profits split after that.
- Capital calls: whether you could be asked for more money, and what happens if you decline.
- Exit and liquidity: how and when you can get your money out, and any penalties.
Where does the projected return fit?
Last. Once you trust the team and understand the structure, the projection becomes useful because you can test it. Ask what assumptions drive it: rent growth, occupancy, exit cap rate, interest rates. Then ask what the return looks like if each assumption is a bit worse than planned. A sponsor who has already run those scenarios, and will share them, is showing you how they think about risk.
How does it fit with the rest of an executive’s wealth?
Many executives hold a large share of their net worth in a single place: company stock, options and a salary from the same employer. That concentration is worth keeping in mind when you look at private investments.
Private real estate can add exposure that doesn’t move with the stock market day to day, and some structures pay regular income. It also locks up capital, often for years. Before committing, map out:
- Your liquidity calendar: option exercises, vesting schedules, tax bills, tuition and any planned home purchase.
- Your income needs: whether you want distributions now or growth later.
- Your total real estate exposure: including your own home and any rental property you already hold.
- Restrictions from your employer: some companies require approval for outside investments or board roles.
Then size any commitment so a long lockup, or a loss, wouldn’t force you to sell other holdings at a bad time.
How are other investors thinking about property?
Attitudes toward real estate are shifting in many markets. For example, New Zealand investor confidence data from ASB shows fewer investors picking property as their single best investment, with more interest in managed funds and shares. Many investors still want real estate’s income and diversification. They’re simply more selective about how they hold it, and who manages it.
Frequently asked questions
1. Do I need to be an accredited investor?
For most private real estate offerings, yes. Rules and thresholds are set by the SEC, and sponsors may need to verify your status.
2. How much of a portfolio should go into private real estate?
There’s no universal number. It depends on your income needs, time horizon and how much illiquidity you can handle. Discuss it with a financial advisor who knows your full picture.
3. Is a fund safer than a single-property deal?
A fund spreads risk across more properties, but it still depends on one manager’s judgment. A single-property syndication lets you pick the exact asset, which some investors prefer when they know the market well. Diversification reduces single-property risk, but sponsor risk remains.
The bottom line
Executives already know how to evaluate a deal: start with the people, read the terms, then test the forecast. Apply that same discipline to private real estate, commit only capital you can leave in place for years, and remember that any private investment can lose money.
This article is for educational purposes and isn’t investment, tax or legal advice.


